Too Close To Call: BigTime Murder vs. Mysteriously Yours

We pit BigTime Murder against Mysteriously Yours to determine which dinner theatre follows in the footsteps of Sherlock Holmes. Who knows their audience better? You decide. 

 

BIGTIME MURDER

vs.

MYSTERIOUSLY YOURS

 
Peter Dillon (president-at-large), Janet Davidson, 1992
 
Position
and year
established:

 
Lili and Brian Caws (co-producers) and Iliki Mahairas (front), 1987 
 
Up to 200 — it all depends on the year.
 
How many
shows a year?
Usually about 250 or so.
 
Many! But the biggest VIPs were the Canadian troops that we had the honour of entertaining in the Persian Gulf in January 2003.
 
Any celebrity spottings? Joan Rivers has attended two shows.
Mike Holmes attended the opening
night of Extreme Holmes Makeover:
Murder Edition.
 
We never force anyone to get involved but we definitely encourage active participation. A guest can also play the surprise victim ­and stumble into the
room with a pair of scissors sticking out of his back. 
 
Do you always involve the dinner guests?
 
 
Yes, we have places in the mysteries
where we are going to use audience members. We incorporate people celebrating birthdays or anniversaries into the show as minor characters.
 
 
Listen to the details and keep an eye on the characters. All culprits need a motive, opportunity and means … unless it was an accident!
What’s the key to solving a murder mystery?

 

Paying attention to all the details
and clues and deducing what is out of place or shouldn’t have been known
by a character.  

 

Never!

 

 

How often is the butler the culprit?
 
 
Agatha Christie never had the butler as the culprit. However, we have a butler in [our current show] Uptown Abbey, so … one never knows.… It’s a mystery. 
Poison ink. Although there can be blood, we don’t do over-the-top blood and guts.… It’s dinner theatre after all.
 
 
 

Most unique murder weapon used?

 

 

A dart from a blow gun, used by
the Unga-Bunga tribe.

 
 
 

 

Article exclusive to POST CITY