North York Community councillors were unable to reach a decision about whether or not a condominium development proposal that would add 1,300 units to the neighbourhood should be built on the site next to the Shops at Don Mills.

The proposal, submitted by Cadillac Fairview, called for a mixed-use development of six buildings with heights ranging from 12 to 26 storeys. The plan also calls for the conversion of a 13-storey office building currently occupying 75 The Donway West as well as the developer’s offer to fund construction of a two-storey community centre.

Following five hours of discussion at a community council meeting, only six of the 11 councillors remained. Those still in attendance were unable to make a recommendation for the proposal.

“The impression I am getting from my constituents is that they believe that they have not been provided with all the facts nor the dramatic impact that this development application will have,” said Coun. Denzil Minnan-Wong. He added that suggested densities in the proposal are similar to those along the subway corridor.

Don Mills residents are divided on the proposal.

“We’re very much in support of it,” said Terry West, president of Don Mills Residents Inc., who said the new centre will serve the changing neighbourhood as more young families move in to the area. He added that his group sent out 1,300 questionnaires about the proposal. Roughly 85 per cent of respondents were in favour, he said.

"It is definitely not an accurate representation of the community," said Simone Gabbay, founder of Don Mills Friends, who said many area residents never received the questionnaire. In addition to traffic and density worries, Gabbay said she is concerned that the conversion of 75 The Donway West will displace health-care providers using the building, impacting area residents.